By Mark A. York (August 30, 2019)
Medical Errors Are Third Leading Cause of Death in the U.S.
Are 10 percent of U.S. deaths due to preventable medical mistakes?
Medical errors are an “epidemic” that claim hundreds of thousands of lives annually, according to medical reports.
MEDICAL ERRORS ARE THE third leading cause of death in the U.S., after heart disease and cancer, causing at least 250,000 deaths every year, according to recently released data indicating that patient safety efforts fall far short.
Types of PAEs
The cause of PAEs in hospitals may be separated into these categories:
- Errors of commission,
- Errors of omission,
- Errors of communication,
- Errors of context, and
- Diagnostic errors
“People don’t just die from heart attacks and bacteria, they die from system-wide failings and poorly coordinated care,” says the study’s lead author, Dr. Martin Makary, a professor of surgery and health policy at Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine. “It’s medical care gone awry.”
Medical errors rank behind heart disease and cancer as the third leading cause of death in the U.S., Johns Hopkins researchers say. … Based on an analysis of prior research, the Johns Hopkins study estimates that more than 250,000 Americans die each year from medical errors.
Historical analysis of papers that focused on mortality due to medical errors in 1999-2000, took a number of different approaches and perspectives, summarized in, “To Err is Human” which estimated that 44,000 to 98,000 deaths per year were due to medical error. There was an uproar, and many pundits dismissed it out of hand. Using a weighted average of four previous studies, a meta-analysis in 2013 “A New, Evidence-based Estimate of Patient Harms Associated with Hospital Care” estimated more than 400,000 deaths due to medical error per year. In 2016, “Medical error—the third leading cause of death in the US” estimated 251,454 deaths, based on 35,416,020 hospitalization.
Objectives Based on 1984 data developed from reviews of medical records of patients treated in New York hospitals, the Institute of Medicine estimated that up to 98,000 Americans die each year from medical errors. The basis of this estimate is nearly 3 decades old; herein, an updated estimate is developed from modern studies published from 2008 to 2011.
Methods A literature review identified 4 limited studies that used primarily the Global Trigger Tool to flag specific evidence in medical records, such as medication stop orders or abnormal laboratory results, which point to an adverse event that may have harmed a patient. Ultimately, a physician must concur on the findings of an adverse event and then classify the severity of patient harm.
Results Using a weighted average of the 4 studies, a lower limit of 210,000 deaths per year was associated with preventable harm in hospitals. Given limitations in the search capability of the Global Trigger Tool and the incompleteness of medical records on which the Tool depends, the true number of premature deaths associated with preventable harm to patients was estimated at more than 400,000 per year. Serious harm seems to be 10- to 20-fold more common than lethal harm.
Conclusions The epidemic of patient harm in hospitals must be taken more seriously if it is to be curtailed. Fully engaging patients and their advocates during hospital care, systematically seeking the patients’ voice in identifying harms, transparent accountability for harm, and intentional correction of root causes of harm will be necessary to accomplish this goal.
In a Mayo Clinic study with the American College of Surgeons, 8.9% of participating U.S. surgeons reported the belief that they’ve made a major medical error within the last 3 months — and 1.5% believe their error resulted in a patient’s death, according to Tait Shanafelt. “When you think about that for a minute, it’s a staggering number,” Shanafelt says. Suicide ideation doubles in that 3-month window as well, he notes, independent of depression — the risk of which triples. “So when we make mistakes — and all physicians will make mistakes during the course of their career — it has a substantial toll on us. And there’s a strong link there with burnout.”
The magnitude of the death toll – roughly 10 percent of U.S. deaths annually – is striking coming, as it does, in an era dominated by efforts to reform the health system to ensure safe, high quality, high-value medical care. Patient
no systematic effort to study medical errors or to put effective safeguards in place.
“Throughout the world, medical error leading to patient death is an under-recognized epidemic,” Makary and his co-author, Dr. Michael Daniel, also of Johns Hopkins, write in Tuesday’s British Medical Journal. They define medical errors as lapses in judgment, skill or coordination of care; mistaken diagnoses; system failures that lead to patient deaths or the failure to rescue dying patients; and preventable complications of care.
Their report comes nearly two decades after “To Err is Human,” a report by the Institute of Medicine, asserted that medical mistakes are rampant in health care. The IOM, a quasi-public think tank made up of leading scientists, drew on existing data to estimate that 44,000 to 98,000 people die in U.S. hospitals each year. Even then, some researchers claimed the estimates were low and based on outdated information.
The new estimate is drawn from more-recent studies indicating the number may be much higher. For instance, a report published in the journal Health Affairs in 2011 calculated that just over 1 percent of hospital patients die each year because of medical errors. When applied to the more than 35 million people hospitalized each year, Makary and Daniel say, this would “translate into 400,201 deaths per year, more than four times the original IOM report estimate.”
The Hopkins team used evidence from four studies that analyzed medical death rate data from 2000 to 2008, including one by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services’ Office of the Inspector General and the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality. Using these data, they were able to calculate a mean death rate for medical errors in U.S. hospitals. Applying this rate to the 35 million admissions in 2013, they calculated that 251,454 deaths resulted from medical mistakes.
The researchers acknowledge that this figure most likely represents an undercount, because they were unable to capture data from deaths that occur in outpatient clinics, nursing homes and other non-hospital settings where health care workers care for fragile patients who need complex care.
“It’s fair to say that this number is controversial,” says Dr. Robert Wachter, a professor of medicine at UCSF School of Medicine. “I wouldn’t take this number to the bank.”
Dr. Ashish Jha, a patient-safety expert and director of the Harvard Global Health Institute, agreed that many researchers will be temped to debate which of the estimates are the most accurate.
“It doesn’t matter,” he says, “because all these numbers are so big. They’re a reminder of how big the problem is and how little is being done to address it.”
Much of the effort put into patient safety and performance improvement over the last two decades has been misdirected or ineffective, Jha says. “If you called the CEO of a big hospital and asked, ‘How many medical errors did you have last month? How many falls? How many falls that resulted in serious injury?’ They won’t know.”
Another issue, Wachter says, is that patient safety is being crowded out by newer initiatives. “My concern,” he says, “is that patient safety efforts, which gained so much momentum following the publication of the IOM report, have lost ground in recent years, defused by all the other performance improvement mandates that have come down the highway.”
Makary and Daniel are calling for reforms that would improve the reporting of medical errors, which in turn could inform prevention efforts. In a letter dated May 1, they asked the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, which gathers births, deaths and other vital statistics, to rank medical errors on the list of leading causes of death. They also asked CDC to alter death certificates so that doctors, medical examiners and coroners can routinely report medical errors that contribute to a patient’s death.
The letter takes pains to point out that the U.S. government and private sector spend “a lot of money” on heart disease and cancer research and prevention. “It is time for the country to invest [a proportional amount] in medical quality and patient safety,” it says.
So far, the researchers have not received an official response, but CDC officials acknowledged that errors are under-reported and that there are ways to capture the data, Makary says. CDC experts were not available for comment.
Wachter is skeptical that the practice of using death certificates to report medical errors will take hold among doctors. “The idea they’ll begin recording this faithfully, or without concern for a malpractice suit, doesn’t strike me as very plausible,” he says.
Makary adds that it was his perception that medical-error research is “underfunded and under-appreciated” that prompted him to embark on an analysis that would elevate fatal mishaps to their proper place near the top of the list of all causes of death.
The findings, Jha says, illustrate that the policies and practices we’re putting in place “are completely inadequate to the size of the problem we have.”
“We can do this,” Jha says. “This is not beyond the creativity and ingenuity of the health care community. We’ve just got to make it a real priority.”
At what point do US consumers start to realize that the healthcare system in the United states is not geared toward “health care” but toward making profits for the medical industry as a whole. Which includes- Big Pharma, For-profit hospitals (owned by non-profits), insurance companies, third party benefit providers, pharmacies that pay and receive rebates (pay to play kickbacks) from drug makers and distributors, doctors paid by Big Pharma to author slanted medical papers and the list goes on and on.