Indiana Jury Awards Tonya Brand $3 million In Damages
By Staff (February 6, 2019)
(MASS TORT NEXUS MEDIA) A federal jury awarded plaintiff Tonya Brand $3 million in the most recent Cook MDL 2570 IVC Filter bellwether trial on February 1, 2019 in Indianapolis. See Tonya Brand v. Cook IVC Filter Jury Verdict Form Feb 1, 2019 , where the jury determined that the design of the Cook Celect IVC Filter was defective and returned a verdict of $3 million dollars.
The jury declined to award punitive damages against Cook Medical, Inc. with Ms. Brand’s trial counsel, Misty Farris offering “we are happy with the jury verdict and are encouraged that the Celect IVC Filter was recognized as being defectively designed, as far as punitive damages not being awarded—we respect the jury decision to not award punitives and look forward to the next trial.” See Tonya Brand v Cook Punitive Jury Instructions Feb 5, 2019.
Ms. Farris further added, “We believe this was the right verdict and perhaps the defense may consider this when determining whether or not to begin settlement discussions,” as there are no other bellwether trials scheduled in the Cook MDL 2570 following the Tonya Brand trial. Will this verdict move Cook Medical and its legal team toward the start of settlement negotiations?
The Brand trial is just one of the more than 5,000 cases filed against Cook Medical, Inc. and its affiliates, where plaintiffs are alleging its blood clot filters were defectively designed. Ms. Brand’s attorneys offered to the jury that she pulled a part of her Cook IVC filter out of her thigh in 2011 after it broke up and deteriorated, while pieces of the device remain lodged in in other areas of her body and are unable to be removed. For additional information on the Cook IVC Filter MDL 2750 docket see Cook-Medical IVC-Filter-MDL-2570-Docket Briefcase, by Mass Tort Nexus.
In addition to Misty Farris, of Dallas-based Fears Nachawati, the trial team consisted of Ben Martin of the Law Offices of Ben C. Martin; Denman Heard, of the Heard Law Firm; Laura Baughman, with Baron & Budd and Joseph Williams of Indiana-based Riley Williams & Piatt, with a sincere congratulations to the entire team on their trial victory!
The Brand jury verdict came in the third bellwether trial in the Cook IVC MDL 2750, after two previous cases selected for trial resulted in wins for Cook.
Cook promoted its Celect IVC filter which was implanted into Ms. Brand as retrievable, but the filters often tilt and pierce the inferior vena cava, or pieces break off and may travel to the duodenum and aorta as well as other parts of the body, resulting in metal fragments pressing against the spine and other critical areas and organs, making it impossible to remove without major surgery. Many times the filter migration requires multiple attempts at surgical removals which fail due to the location of where the metal IVC filter fragments have migrated to.
What is an IVC Filter?
An inferior vena cava (IVC) filter is a small device surgically inserted into the inferior vena cava, the largest vein in the body. These devices, resembling a cage with spindly legs, are designed to trap blood clots from traveling to the lungs and causing a pulmonary embolism. A pulmonary embolism is a potentially fatal blockage of an artery that carries blood from the heart to the lungs. The idea is that the clots will dissolve naturally once trapped in the filter. Some filters are permanent, but otherwise the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) recommends removing the filter between the 29th and 54th day after the filter is implanted, unless the threat of pulmonary embolism hasn’t subsided. The FDA concluded this specific time span based on a mathematical model they developed using available medical data. When the agency discovered this, they did issue a safety notice in 2010 and again in 2014 outlining the risks of leaving the devices in for too long.
Plaintiff claims include that Cook knew its Celect IVC filter had perforation problems before it was cleared by the FDA, yet pushed it to the market anyway. There are independent studies that found Celect had a perforation rate of greater than 79 percent, while the Cook-sponsored study the company presented to the FDA prior to Celect’s 510(k) clearance in 2008 showed a zero percent perforation rate.
Over 9000 IVC Filter Claims Filed
Since 1979 when IVC filters were first introduced, hundreds of thousands of IVC filters have been implanted in patients. In August 2010, the FDA issued a safety communication stating IVC filters “are not always removed,” and known long term IVC filter risks include lower limb deep vein thrombosis, filter fracture, filter migration, filter embolization and IVC perforation. There are now over 9,000 IVC filter lawsuits pending against Cook Medical, Johnson & Johnson, C.R. Bard, Cordis Corporation, B. Braun, Rex Medical, and other manufacturers in state and federal courts.
What are the risks of an inferior vena cava filter placement?
- Excess bleeding
- Allergic reaction
- Damage to the blood vessel at the insertion site
- Blockage of blood flow through the vena cava, which can cause leg swelling
- A filter that travels to the heart or lungs, causing injury or death
- A filter that pierces through the inferior vena cava, causing pain or damage to other organs
- Problem with placement of the filter
- Continued risk of a blood clot that travels to the lungs
Clinical Research Shows IVC Filter Dangers Were Known
“Caval Penetration by Inferior Vena Cava Filters”
https://doi.org/10.1161/CIRCULATIONAHA.115.016468 Circulation. 2015;132:944–952
Blood clot filters are implanted in an estimated 250,000 people in the U.S. each year, most without incident. In the last decade, millions of filters have been implanted in Americans and Cook Medical, Inc. is justone of 11 manufacturers that make these devices and are involved in litigation pending in both federal and state court dockets across the country.
To access the most relevant and real time information on Mass Torts sign up for:
Mass Tort Nexus “CLE Immersion Course”
March 8-11, 2019 at The Riverside Hotel in Fort Lauderdale , FL
For class attendance information please contact Jenny Levine at 954.520.4494 or Jenny@masstortnexus.com.
- For the most up-to-date information on all MDL dockets and related mass torts visit www.masstortnexus.com and review our mass tort briefcases and professional site MDL briefcases.
- To obtain our free newsletters that contains real time mass tort updates, visit.www.masstortnexus.com/news and sign up for free access.
(Disclaimer: Excerpts in this document and media content may have originated in other media publications)